The Invisible Force Holding Back Your Fitness Progress: Cognitive Dissonance

Ever wonder why despite your best intentions, consistent progress seems just out of reach? There's likely something going on psychologically that is silently sabotaging your efforts…

What Is Cognitive Dissonance?

Cognitive dissonance is that uncomfortable feeling when your actions don't align with your beliefs. Your brain hates this inconsistency and will do whatever it takes to resolve it – often in ways that don't serve your long-term goals.

Instead of changing behavior to match your stated values, your mind creates justifications, excuses, and rationalizations to protect your ego and maintain comfort (often meaning the status quo).

Real-World Examples of Cognitive Dissonance in Fitness

• Joe crushes his workouts Monday through Friday, then spends the weekend destroying his progress with "I deserve this" behavior. His brain justifies this by thinking, "I worked hard and was good all week. I earned this and these choices don't count" – even though deep down, he knows they do.

• Brittany diligently tracks her breakfast and lunch in MacrosFirst, but "forgets" to log the handful of M&Ms from the office candy jar or deliberately underestimates the portion size of the pasta she had for dinner to avoid seeing what she didn't want to see. "It was just a few bites" or "That wasn't a full cup of pasta" becomes her internal dialogue – even as she wonders why her progress has stalled despite her "perfect" tracking.

• Marie keeps saying, "I want to be someone who prioritizes my health," but repeatedly chooses convenience over commitment. Her brain resolves this by creating elaborate excuses why "this time is different" instead of acknowledging the pattern.

How to Recognize When Cognitive Dissonance Is Present

The first step to overcoming cognitive dissonance is recognizing when it's happening. Here are some telltale signs:

• You feel defensive or immediately start justifying your choices

• You dismiss evidence that contradicts what you want to believe

• You compare yourself to others who are "worse" to feel better

• You use words like "just," "only," or "everybody does it" frequently

• You feel a knot in your stomach when thinking about certain habits

Breaking Free: How to Create Change and Do Cool Shit

1. Embrace the Discomfort

When you feel that twinge of dissonance, pause. Don't rush to resolve it. Sit with the uncomfortable truth that your actions and beliefs are misaligned – this awareness is the first step to change.

2. Update Your Beliefs or Your Actions

One has to change. Either admit that your current fitness level is exactly what your behaviors are designed to achieve (update beliefs) OR change your behaviors to align with your stated goals (update actions).

3. Create Micro-Commitments

Break down big goals or ideals into tiny, non-negotiable daily actions. It's harder for your brain to rationalize away small, specific commitments than vague intentions.

4. Practice Ruthless Honesty

Start a "dissonance journal" where you document moments of disconnect between what you say matters and what you actually do. No judgment – just data.

The people who make extraordinary progress aren't the ones with superhuman willpower. They're the ones who are aware and use that awareness to grow - they recognize cognitive dissonance and resolve it by changing their actions, not their excuses.

Questions to Reflect On

Take some time to honestly consider these questions:

1. Where in your health & fitness journey are you telling yourself a story that protects your comfort rather than challenges your growth?

2. If your actions were the only evidence available, what would they say about what truly matters to you?

3. Think of the last time you "slipped up" with your nutrition or workout plan. What was the first thought that came to mind? Was it taking ownership or creating justification?

4. What would happen if you approached your next workout or meal with complete honesty about your intentions and effort?

5. What conversation are you avoiding having with yourself about the gap between your goals and your daily habits?

Remember, cool shit is on the other side of doing. Set aside some time to reflect on these questions and dig in deeply. The discomfort you feel might just be the growing pain of real progress.

Want more insights like this? Sign up for my newsletter, where I share strategies for behavior change that actually works.